Painted Pony in Betdlehem

74 Main St S, Betdlehem, CT 06751-2001, Betdlehem

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Italian
  • Pub
Features
  • Takeout
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Buffet
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Parking Available
  • Free Off-Street Parking
  • Television
  • Highchairs Available
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Full Bar
  • Accepts American Express
  • Accepts Mastercard
  • Accepts Visa
  • Free Wifi
  • Accepts Discover
  • Reservations
  • Accepts Credit Cards
Good for
  • Families witd children
  • Kids
  • Large groups

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

We purchased a gift card in July. Can we get out money back?

Nope they are out of business,😯

What happened, we used to go here all the time. I love the egg lemon soup. Please open up again soon

Sounds like negotiations broke down between the owner of the facility and the folks that ran the business.

Is this place closed for good?

The painted pony has been reopened :-)

What is the menu for the senior lunch?

Not sure..but the meals i have had always good

Will you be serving turkey for Christmas?

Closed today Christmas

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Painted Pony
DS
Dave S
google
11.22.2024
4/5

Elated The Painted Pony has reopened.Excellent food with good portions which are served by attentive staff.We could definitely do without having staff stand at attention watching the diners.Very uncomfortable situation.The irony is these same people walked by our table repeatedly and failed to remove garbage, plates and didn't fill water glasses.

Painted Pony
EF
Ellie F.J.
google
09.17.2018
5/5

Good food. Lite food menu for small appetites. Nice beer selection.

Painted Pony
JM
Jan Marino
google
07.09.2018
2/5

What a disappointing experience. Ordered 4 soups to start. The 3 lemon/rice soups were very good. The Rhode Island clam chowder was mainly just broth, hardly any clams, and had a hair in it. Ordered a burger medium, cheddar and onions only. It came well done with American cheese, not cheddar. Dad ordered a Burger on white toast, well done, American cheese lettuce and tomato. His came on a roll (not white toast) and was medium, not well done. Also, they put his Burger on my plate and my Burger on his plate. My husband's flat bread was soggy, sitting on a bed of oil or grease. Again just very disappointing overall. Not sure I'd go back.

Painted Pony
ML
Mike Longenbaker
google
07.08.2018
3/5

Our 1st time here, reasonable prices, small portions. Examples: soup is served in a shallow bowl, fish-chips is a lunch portion at most place, potato wedges and up to 3/4 of a potato. Watch out for the sides which are extremely expensive for thier size- 5 small piece of broccoli for $5.Our server was a Great server!

Painted Pony
GZ
Gregory Zaczkiewicz
google
06.06.2018
5/5

Food was excellent and the sevice was great. The Restaurant has a lot of charm very well decorated. It came highly recommended from those in town.

Painted Pony
MC
Mickey Corcoran
google
06.04.2018
4/5

The wife and I went there today and we were very happy that the food (prime rib) was just as good as always, service and atmosphere GREAT 😋

Painted Pony
NP
Nicole Perez
google
03.17.2018
4/5

Good food, Excellent service! Our waiter was attentive, and very pleasant. While he was serving other tables the bartender and additional waitstaff made sure our drinks were filled and we had everything we needed.

Painted Pony
AM
Ann Marie Tozzi
google
02.20.2018
2/5

This was our 1st visit and we were not impressed. We arrived at 4:45 and wanted to order a baked potato with our dinner but were told that they do not serve them until 5:00. The service was not great but the food we ordered was good. We would not go back

Painted Pony
RS
Roger Sinclair
google
10.14.2017
5/5

We had a fantastic time at this spot. We loved the amazing vibes and the menu. The staff members were very welcoming. I’m content we ultimately managed to visit here.

Painted Pony
DR
Duane Rose
google
10.06.2017
5/5

Great food and service....

Painted Pony
DC
Debra Cruz
google
07.22.2017
5/5

I went here with my client and her husband it was great really good food and the boss is always making sure you are OK and the workers I will definitely let people know to go there

Painted Pony
EM
Ed Miller
google
05.16.2017
4/5

As of Aug. 2018 the Painted Pony has ceased operation, unfortinately, Reasonably priced. Portions are large. So, be prepared to take a doggie bag home with you. There is also a very-reasonably priced "Lite Faire" menu. The dining room is quieter than the lounge/bar area and has the same menu. The wait staff is very personable and very attentive to your needs. The Painted Pony has reopened, but I have not visited as of 03/17/20.

Painted Pony
AM
Angela Molina
google
02.07.2017
4/5

Went to see THE RAKES perform. They're great...service was not. Food was disappointing. Ordered tenderloin medallions medium, they came out well and Server never checked on us to see how the food was so we ate what we could but it wasn't good overall. The band did a fantastic job. Pro tip- eat before you go there.

Painted Pony
ML
Mary Luth
google
10.15.2016
2/5

MUCH TO LOUD. Could not have a conversation with friends we were with.Prime rib special was very good but overpriced. Waitress wasn't sure about several menu items. Had to keep checking with the kitchen to answer our questions. The rolls were stale. No one our table received the vegetables that were supposed to be part our meals. A baked potato was served with blue cheese salad dressing instead of butter and sour cream. Two people in our party didn't have knives to cut their prime rib. Had to ask.It appears they are still trying to get organized as it's only been open for a couple of weeks. It was not a pleasant experience.

Painted Pony
JM
John Mauceri
google
10.09.2016
4/5

Nice atmosphere, good service, good wings.

Painted Pony
GB
Greg Brick
google
09.09.2016
4/5

Nice friendly place. Good food. Entertainment weekly. Room for events. Large covered deck with a fireplace for spring, summer, and fall dining.

Painted Pony
as
aaron swift
google
07.02.2016
5/5

Very good food and reasonably priced! Nice place to go for a prime rib dinner!

Painted Pony
BR
Billy Rico
google
05.27.2016
2/5

Did not care for the Easter buffet. The service was bad, couldn't keep up with plates for guests and once dessert was gone, it was gone. Plus they automatically took 20% gratuity. I wouldn't of minded that if the service was decent.

Painted Pony
jm
jeanna may
google
04.22.2016
5/5

Food was excellent! Great service. Very friendly..will go again..

Painted Pony
RT
Ronald Tartaglia
google
04.13.2016
5/5

The ago-lemono soup is to die for. Great food steaks and burgers are always awesome. Honey mustard pork chops are Manhattan Exquisite at a small little Connecticut restaurant. If you're real lucky you'll be there when they make the once in a blue moon and stuffed pepper soup it is out of this world

Painted Pony
PM
Peter March
google
03.07.2016
5/5

I was here for a party. It was a very nice place. Food was typical for cater food. Too far for me to visit again as it's in the boondocks ☺

Painted Pony
DZ
Debbi Zappone
google
03.04.2016
4/5

Went to a memorial brunch buffet. Relaxed atmosphere, service and food was good. Will probably return to try dinner.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12032665771

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!